The market is not rigged against your investment success – your brain is

The human brain is reasonably well adapted to confrontation – we need only look at the “fight or flight” response which, through a surge in adrenaline not only jumpstarts alertness but also immediately prepares musculature for physical defense. What the brain doesn’t like, possibly above all other stimulus, is randomness, the consistent concern that some superior, little-understood force like disease, lightning or an overhead leopard could pop out of the sky at any time.  SOAT described it thusly: “from the time we stood on two legs, exposing our internal organs in a way unlike any other mammal, the human brain has been oriented around fear.”  For proof, he pointed to early polytheism where individual gods were assigned control over aspects of life like war, agriculture, love or the ocean, where people felt most beset by random factors. Sacrificing a goat before a long sea voyage or during planting seasons provided the illusion of control, decreasing the fear of a boat-swamping storm or hail that could wipe out a crop.  The seductive notion of fate, that our futures are written in a book somewhere, is another central outgrowth of the way in which psychology struggles with random outcomes.  At a subconscious level, we’d rather be under the control of a superior being than admit the full extent of luck and circumstance as a determining force.

Investing markets thus provide an interesting psychological challenge resulting from their daily, seemingly random volatility.  Slitting the throats of unsuspecting farm animals being frowned upon in modern society, the coping mechanisms for this have evolved, and conspiracy theories are primary among them. The frustration of losing money in the market, exacerbated by its implications for future social status, can lead to a desperate form of pattern seeking where someone must be blamed.  Finding a villain not only makes investing losses non-random and intelligible, but also provides a solution – burn that culprit at the stake and then I can be free to generate consistent, outsized returns before retiring to my own island in the Caribbean at age 45.

The reason I do not generally proscribe to conspiracy theories is not because I don’t believe there are groups powerful enough to design them. I just don’t think any group of people larger than ten is capable of keeping it quiet for longer than three months. Consider the Plunge Protection Team theory for a minute. It’s not hard to believe that Bernanke and Geithner would benefit, and have the means, to surreptitiously boost asset values in after hours trading. But, think also about how difficult it would be to keep this secret. These are huge trades and no investment bank is going to accept a $200 million check from an anonymous account to settle them. There will be inevitable clearing problems and if a Morgan Stanley back office clerk has to call a Langley Virginia area code and speak to someone who refuses to give their real name in order to sort them out, this information would spread to the trading floor, a place where rumors compete with oxygen in term of necessity, in less than 10 minutes. We’d know by now.

Conspiracy theories are not the only area where the human brain has been empirically proven to make us bad investors. The unchallenged king of sources for detailing them is the Psy-Fi blog. I can virtually guarantee that anyone who has made more than 20 trades in their lives can read Psy-Fi’s list of most common investor mistakes HERE, and recount making at least half of them. Don’t even bother emailing me if you think you haven’t – I’d sooner believe you’ve never had a craving for sugar or sex.  In short, no investors’ education is complete without reading this list or a similarly detailed explication of investor psychology.

The market then, is not rigged against your investment success– you’re brain is. Every investor will look for patterns where none exist and blame the wrong people when it doesn’t work out. The same skepticism you show when a software salesperson comes into your office proclaiming to “improve productivity by 15%” will magically disappear when your broker calls. You will be sorely tempted to climb on market bandwagons late, after a huge run, because of a herding instinct perfectly adapted to the Neanderthal era. You will make important investment “sell” decisions based on the arbitrary price at which you bought the stock and you will fall in love with a current holding that is more likely to torpedo your portfolio than recover to book value.  Your broker and the 1% are not to blame; they are just making it easy for you to do what your brain already wants you to.

9 thoughts on “The market is not rigged against your investment success – your brain is

  1. LL says:

    I have always believed that proper psychology is 90% of trading. Knowing yourself is far more important than mastery of a system at least in my experience.

    Trading and single player sports like wrestling or tennis have many parallels. I have found that the lessons I learned about myself from these sports have translated well into trading.

    This was a great article, I look forward to reading more of your work.

    • Interloper says:

      Absolutely. The “know yourself” lesson of Art of War is always ignored in favor of the more entertaining attack-related parts. Sports also teaches how to lose even if we’ve done our best, which i think is key. Thanks for comment.

  2. […] Interloper, “The market then, is not rigged against your investment success– you’re brain is.” (The Interloper) […]

  3. […] clothes (FT.com) • The market is not rigged against your investment success – your brain is (Interloper) • Growing Economies, Stagnant Wages (Economix) • Italy’s ‘shock therapy’ as […]

  4. ToNYC says:

    Beyond reptilian stasis, humans seek satisfaction and can live dynamically with many species. The dirty short-cut this pirate/whore culture worships is that stored value credits can somehow cut to sufficient satisfaction.
    All this is just living on a burning fuse or a re-fi not rolling.
    Respecting the rights of others: the kindergarten rule is the doorway to learning from other species; and if you listen well enough, you might teach the less fortunate who will later help you from gratitude rather than payment book.

  5. rpseawright says:

    Just a note to say how much I enjoy this blog. Thank you.

  6. Rich and Co. says:

    By definition, markets evolved to take our money not make us money. Moralizing about this process and reality is a waste of problem-solving time.

    • Interloper says:

      There is a difference between “take” and “attract”. The markets become more dangerous for investors in the same way network tv became crap – by appealing to base emotion. I wrote this post as a marginal encouragement for investors to understand why what they feel may be undercutting their success – a process every professional trader goes through. Clearly I disagree that it was a waste of time.

  7. Adam Collins says:

    I was spoiled when I grew up and was told for too long that everything I did was great and that I was somehow special. This sense of entitlement translated into extreme over-confidence in the trading world and made me say goodbye to $25,000 before I turned 19. I’ve spent the majority of 2011 starting from square one in my trading education and knowing that 1) the only thing I can control are my own actions 2) the market doesn’t care what I think and 3) successful trading takes time and reflection on how you react to your own emotions (not searching for yet another winning strategy). After my one year anniversary of thinking “Keep my out of the money calls that have tripled overnight into the earnings announcement… WHY NOT?” I’ll say that holding anything except your own brain responsible for trading decisions is ridiculous.

    P.S. Love the site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 202 other followers

%d bloggers like this: