Reading Fiction Will Make You a Better Investor

I know I’m not stupid. But even though I was always among the three brightest kids in class I have a good friend who, right brain or left brain, is quicker than me in every way. He, in turn, tells a story about a visiting professor who was writing the answer to a question on a blackboard and was asked a second question, after which he wrote the answer to that with his left hand, while finishing the answer to the first with his right. My buddy’s response was, “Well, I’m smart, but I’m nowhere near that gifted”.  The investing lesson here was that if I was just going to think linearly, along the same path as everyone else, someone with significantly higher brain horsepower was going to get there first, and potentially earlier enough to be filling my bid to take profits.

But the fact that my family history involved frequent displacement early on turned out to be a lucky break – the “making new friends” lag time was spent reading, fiction, to the point where the habit became permanently ingrained. Unwittingly, I was learning lessons in empathy that would make me a much better investor.

There are obvious examples of this. David Liss’ “Conspiracy of Paper” provided a highly enjoyable depiction of the collapse of the South Seas bubble in the early 18th century, with the commensurate motivations of businessmen, government and criminal gangs. Through the fictionalized account, it was clear that the South Seas bubble, the result of abuse of the new Limited Liability structure, is roughly but usefully analogous to the recent securitization/financial product/CDO upheaval. The investing-related utility of other novels is more subtle. Wolfe’s Bonfire of the Vanities (the book, not the wretched movie) is more than 20 years old but continues to provide insight into the hubris and social abstraction of the new “Masters of the Universe”, hedge fund managers. Aksyonov’s criminally under-read “Generations of Winter” has nothing to do with finance but does, by presenting the horrors inherent in Stalin-era Russia, provide context for how messed up the present leadership, and by extension the economy, of Russia truly are. In more contemplative moments, you can gauge the mood of oppressed Chinese against oppressed Russians.

Unlike historical accounts, through well-drawn characters it is possible to absorb the world through another perspective, an immensely valuable skill for investors looking for ideas (or trouble). A memory bank of fictional characters will also help when the market “hive mind” pushes prices in unexpected directions, answering the question “what kind of person buys here?”.

The primary lesson of fiction is learning “this is how people act”, when they’re scared, confident, happy, determined or demoralized. Not how I would act, or how I think they should act, but how the combination of different experiences and different patterns of cognition lead to aggregate outcomes. Empathy.

Fiction is the longest-running, most rewarding relationship of my life with little or no adverse side effects, so forgive the evangelical tone. I do believe reading fiction, despite the time-sucking nature of the process, provides a competitive advantage for investors  by providing wider context for decision making. I can’t answer two questions on a blackboard at once, but somewhere I have read a book with a character that will give me an idea how a person who can will react to the markets.

About these ads

19 thoughts on “Reading Fiction Will Make You a Better Investor

  1. Jonas says:

    +1. Even though I’m not a liberal arts major, that’s why I think liberal arts is under-rated by the current college-has-bad-ROI crowd. Orthogonal ways of thinking has value that’s not so easily measured by simple linear models.

  2. [...] Will reading fiction make you a better investor?  (Interloper) [...]

  3. KS says:

    Agree. Though I have to add, you can also get a lot out of the many non-fiction books that specifically delve into human behavior.

  4. John the Financial Engineer says:

    I also enjoyed immensely David Liss’s Conspiracy of Paper. What better way to learn an historical event like South Sea vs. Bank of England rivalry than through points of views of living characters, where the historical event comes alive. Entertaining and educational at the same time.

  5. Duncan says:

    Similar life similar passion. Since you mentioned two of my favorite books how about sharing more of your favorites – I’ll give two of my very obscure finds: ‘Under the Frog’ and ‘A Certain Chemistry’

  6. [...] Economy Quietly Improves (The Daily Beast) • Reading Fiction Will Make You a Better Investor (Interloping) • Where Is the Volcker Rule? (Economix) see also SEC Cops Want to Fight U.S. Judge (WSJ) • [...]

  7. Chad says:

    The professor may have had an operation that severed his corpus callosum, the brain tissue connecting the left and right hemispheres. It’s a treatment option for severe Epilepsy. This would have allowed him to write two answers with both hands simultaneously, since the hemispheres of the brain are basically operating independently of each other.

  8. [...] someone who makes a similar argument about fiction-reading and [...]

  9. [...] major principle of the Qualt Shop, school of thought, fiction: The primary lesson of fiction is learning “this is how people act”, when they’re scared, [...]

  10. GrthzGd says:

    I agree, and the more classic the novel, the less one has a sense afterwards of having wasted one’s time, with the possible exception of the novels of Theodore Dreiser.

  11. [...] Reading Fiction Will Make You a Better Investor [Interloper] [...]

  12. GrthzGd says:

    And don’t forget “King Lear.” Anyone well versed in that Shakespeare great would never even consider giving away his property to his children before death.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 205 other followers

%d bloggers like this: